Doing what’s right for patients demands a culture change

We are pleased to announce the dates of our 2013 Lown Conference:
From Avoidable Care to Right Care

For more information on the 2013 conference, please visit our website:
http://lowninstitute.org/project/2013-lown-conference/

———————————————————————————————————————–

Do what’s right for patients, and cost control will follow.

Until recently, the main framework for thinking about reform has been one of shortages and disparities. That has begun to shift as patients and providers become more aware of the problem of unnecessary or avoidable care. Efforts to improve care and control costs will not be successful unless policymakers, payers, providers, and patients address the problem of avoidable care.

Considerable uncertainty remains. How much care in the US is avoidable? Can we quantify its consequences, in terms of financial impact and harms? What factors drive overutilization and inappropriate medical services, how can we curb it, and do physicians have an ethical duty to do so?

 

Proven, systemic solutions waiting to be found

Hi -  I’m writing from the Yale Global Conference on Health.  The questions of the survey reflect a lack of studying how other advanced countries have learned to control the rise in costs and services that zoomed in the 1960s, until the oil crisis recession of the 1970s. Why is there so much in-attention to how this problem of avoidable care as a SYMPTOM of mis-organization of financing and services? See my course on the answers: STANFORD 2011 Syllabus on Kaiser web:

http://www.kaiseredu.org/Syllabus-Library.aspx?sort=topic&pageno=1&school=Stanford+University

In the US, Kaiser Permanente and a few other whole-system organizations have come up with similar solutions. Our own Veterans Health Administration showed how one can transform wasteful, 2nd-rate care into 1st-rate, efficient care in just ten years. Yet how they do this is not indicated in the choices offered for the survey questions.

In the area of prescribing, there is serious avoidable over-prescribing, which contributes to an epidemic of harmful side effects that cost even more to treat (often by prescribing yet another drug). See the INVERSE BENEFIT LAW on www.pharmamyths.net.

I guess I feel frustrated that most policy thinking about how to avoid unnecessary care and expenses today feels like discussions held in the US, Germany, and France in the early 1970s, after a series of articles at that time about excessive hospitalizations, investigations, operations, and prescriptions…

What makes us do it? – Chuck Kilo

Chuck Kilo, MD, MPH, Chief Medical Officer, Oregon Health & Science University

Understanding root causes for the provision of unnecessary testing, procedures, and treatments is necessary if we are to create effective solutions. The Institute of Medicine has listed 8 drivers for the overuse of resources – (1) malpractice, (2) patient demand, (3) poor evidence-base, (4) fee-for-service, (5) overcapacity of services and providers, (6) poor informed consent without shared decision-making, (7) gaps in education and training, and (8) society’s health culture.

These drives represent systems deficiencies amenable to intervention. Creating the right interventions is possible if we exert the right root cause analyses and subsequent leadership focused on positive system solutions. A key barrier to addressing these drivers is a healthcare culture that places blame externally (i.e., patient demand) while failing to accept responsibility and accountability for outcomes and performance improvement. Physicians and delivery system leaders the primary purveyors, stewards, and overseers of health services have a tendency to blame others for the health system’s performance instead of holding themselves accountable. They tend to blame insurers, the financing system, patients, politicians, society, and the government for healthcare’s poor performance and the provision of avoidable, low value services.

The culture of externalizing blame and poor accountability is evidenced by a lack of cohesive leadership across organizations that accept responsibility for clinical outcomes, patient experience, and the control of the total cost of care. Accountable leadership would seek to understand the drivers of low value, low quality care in order to create system solutions.

The 8 drivers have variable influence on different clinicians based on their personal belief system, training, knowledge of system design, communication skills, and other characteristics. In this session, we will analyze how much the 8 IOM drivers contribute to the overprovision of care. We will examine additional drivers including, for example, the lack of clear performance expectations for clinicians and healthcare leaders, poor accountability systems, and individual and industry tendencies to over-interpret the benefits of many healthcare services.

Complexities of avoiding avoidable care

I’m delighted that discussion of the issue of avoiding avoidable care is beginning to happen.  Its roots go back many years, and I would hope that no one is under the illusion that minimizing, let alone eliminating, avoidable care will be easy.

Beginning about 25 years ago, important work was done in this area by Bob Brook and his colleagues at RAND when they developed and applied the RAND Appropriateness Guidelines for various surgical procedures and invasive diagnostic procedures – e.g., coronary angiography, CABG, carotid endarterectomy, hysterectomy, and others.  The RAND criteria were applied to a huge number of clinical scenarios that might lead to a particular procedure, and performing the procedure for patients with that scenario was then categorized as appropriate, uncertain, or inappropriate/unnecessary.  A major problem was that very few instances were considered inappropriate/unnecessary – i.e., situations in which evidence or expert opinion indicated overwhelmingly that the risks outweighed the benefits.  In the early 1990’s, reviews of patients who had coronary angiography in New York State and also at Harvard Community Health Plan, showed only about 6 percent of the procedures to have been “inappropriate” (Noonan SJ et al: Relationship of Anatomic Disease to Appropriateness Ratings of Coronary Angiography.  Arch Internal Med 1995;155:1209-1213).   Much larger percentages of persons undergoing such a procedure either were of “uncertain” appropriateness, 16 percent, or “appropriate,” 78 percent.  A major question, however, is how many of the procedures are absolutely necessary – i.e., absolutely unavoidable.  We do not have good evidence for knowing that, and I fear that we still have not put in place the necessary processes such as shared decision-making and large outcomes databases for gaining that evidence, which, by the way, for the most part will not come from randomized controlled clinical trials (Schoenbaum SC:  Toward fewer procedures and better outcomes.  JAMA 1993;269:794-796).

The point I want to emphasize is that if a discussion of avoiding avoidable care is limited to the relatively small number of things for which there is blanket evidence that they are always unnecessary, it will be a discussion of the top of the tip of the iceberg.  I hope it will quickly become evident that a) we need to develop better evidence of what is necessary in what circumstances; b) we need to learn how to have difficult conversations with each other and with patients about what we do and do not know about benefits, risks, and costs; and c) we need to have difficult conversations among professionals about errors of omission, commission, and risks of malpractice in order to made significant inroads into avoiding avoidable care.

Excessive Spine Surgery

Heading the class in “Avoidable” is multi-level spinal fusion as a primary treatment for low back pain in patients with degenerative disc disease.  Despite the many disclosures over the past few years in the press and medical journals regarding this important issue the surgeons participating in such excessive surgery have not yet been held accountable for their action, which thereby continues unchecked.  Given the fact that poor behavior does not change unless there are significant consequences for it I would be most appreciative if this conference would spend some time discussing the issue of developing appropriate consequences and even more appropriately, effective behavior modifiers which would also make sense. 

C. Burton

What are the knowledge gaps? – Panelist presentation

Be sure to check out Dr. Larson’s “Knowledge gaps” panelist presentation:

Knowledge Gaps Panel Presentation
Eric B. Larson, MD, MPH, Executive Director, Group Health Research Institute

 

A New Model for Advanced Illness Management – Daniel Hoefer

Daniel R. Hoefer, MD, Outpatient Palliative Care and Hospice, Sharp HospiceCare

The vast majority of healthcare is paid for by a model called fee for service. The physician is paid once a procedure or event occurs. This became the foundation for Medicare reimbursement. At Medicare’s inception this was an acceptable model. Life expectancy was about 68 on average and the cost of care was limited by knowledge and relatively few available services.

Fifty years later however, technology and knowledge have dramatically increased. Unfortunately the culture of care and management of the elderly has not kept pace. (This includes the culture of reimbursement.) The fastest growing segments of the US population are over age 70 – 80. Yet, research historically deliberately excluded these demographics. We now know that the psychosocial needs of patients and families, goals of care and human physiology change as people live longer: http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/nhpco/newsline_201204/#/0.

We furthermore know that originally we had a reactive model of care, both medical and psychosocial. However, when 90% of patients in this country die from the predictable end stages of chronic illness a reactive model achieves inferior results. The hospital unnecessarily becomes a tool to manage late-stage disease.

Since 2007 Sharp Health Care through Sharp HospiceCare has embraced these changes. They have developed a model of transitional care which provides concurrent traditional and palliative management. Patients have complete access to traditionally aggressive treatment strategies but as their disease progresses can participate in aggressive palliative and then aggressive hospice strategies. The course of treatment is guided by the goals of care of the patient, including the fact that most persons do not want to be institutionalized and prefer to stay at home.

By providing a concurrent model of care patients have better quality of life, and their goals of care are respected at decreased cost. Hospitalizations are dramatically decreased. Caregiver and families as well have better outcomes. Sharp HospiceCare is decreasing the cost curve of healthcare, not by decreasing care but by dramatically improving the way it is delivered.

Hospital CEO Panel Overview – David Wennberg

This informal panel aims to be a relaxed but provocative conversation with three hospital executives who are experiencing and managing a transition from fee-for-service and volume-based goals to focusing on value and effectiveness. We’ll hear about their worries and frustrations, as well as their successes, hopes and goals for the future as they push for a high-value delivery system.

We have three excellent members of the panel:

• Nancy Howell Agee, President and CEO, Carilion Clinic
• Jeanette Clough, CEO, Mount Auburn Hospital
• Peter Slavin, MD, President, Massachusetts General Hospital

Mount Auburn and MGH are both early adopters in population based care – both are CMMI Pioneer ACOs and both participate in BCBSMA’s Alternative Quality Contract.  However, while early adopters they are both referral systems for Massachusetts and beyond meaning that they are in a high stakes transition from fee-for-service to population based value reimbursement models.

Carilion Clinic has chosen an different path.  Deciding not to participate in CMS’s ACO efforts they are focusing on the private payer side to change the reimbursement model while continuing to develop their multi-specialty clinic model to meet the care demands of the future.

While I will use the moderator’s prerogative to probe the risks and benefits of this transition if needed, I would prefer to have this panel be an open forum with the discussion driven primarily by members of the audience.

I look forward to seeing you all this week.

David

The Doctor Will See You-If You’re Quick – Shannon Brownlee

Be sure to check out Shannon Brownlee’s recently published story, “The Doctor Will See You-If You’re Quick”, available online at the Daily Beast and in this week’s Newsweek Magazine.

“Doctors target overtreatment” radio discussion

Dr. Vikas Saini and Dr. Christine Cassel, president and CEO of the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation, participated in a segment on WBUR called Doctors target overtreatment and avoidable care.

[An excerpt from the WBUR website] Here in Massachusetts, with global payment systems gaining traction, the idea that more health care doesn’t exactly mean better health care isn’t entirely new.

And with the rising cost of health care, targeting wasteful spending is something almost everyone can get onboard with. But once you start getting specific — that is to say, start talking about this test or that treatment — that’s when you run into trouble.

2014 © Lown Cardiovascular Research Foundation | 21 Longwood Avenue Brookline, MA 02446 USA | P: 617-732-1318 | F: 617-277-0347 | Contact Us
cheap viagra
cheapest uk viagra
buy viagra without a perscription
buy viagra now
buy cheap viagra online july
buy lasix
buy viagra online au
cheap deal viagra
order viagra online in wisconsin
buy viagra locally
buy viagra online paypal vipps
viagra and discovery
buy softtabs viagra
cheap deal deal pill viagra
cheap generic online viagra
purchase levitra online
buy nexium
order generic viagra online
cheap cheap discount sale viagra
cheap gerneric viagra
buy cailis viagra singapore
buy discount online viagra
Buy viagra Baltimore
buy discount price sale viagra viagra
buy online viagra
cheap generic viagra no script
Buy viagra Louisville
order viagra cheap
Buy viagra Portland
buy no online prescription viagra
buy paxil online
buy in online uk viagra
buy viagra online uk
buy buying sale viagra
cheap generic viagra substitute
cheap viagra discount viagra buy viagra
Buy viagra Columbus
viagra and coupon
Buy viagra Philadelphia
Buy viagra Newark
buy viagra cheap online
buy viagra free on internet
cheap discount cialis
Buy viagra Modesto
buy viagra overnight
cheapest online viagra
buy viagra over the counter us
cheap generic viagra overnight delivery
buy viagra cheapest best prices online
buy viagra online without prescription
viagra buying online
order viagra online uk
cheapest site viagra
cheap viagra online a href
buy now viagra
buy viagra cialis levitra online prescription
order viagra overnight shipping
cheapest generic viagra
buy cialis now
buy get online prescription viagra
buy viagra online alternative viagra
cheap pharmacy viagra cialis levitra
cheapest uk supplier viagra
buy viagra in the philippines
cheap kamagra uk viagra
buy free online sale viagra viagra
cialis online
order viagra on line
cheap generic viagra no prescription
cheap viagra in uk
order cheap viagra
Buy viagra Tulsa
purchase cialis online
buy viagra cheapest
buy viagra online australia
buy viagra on the internet
Buy viagra Minneapolis
buy cheap viagra viagra
buy cheapest online place viagra
order viagra air travel php
buy cheap online viagra
discount viagra europe
order viagra now
cheapest viagra world
discount viagra 10 pack generic
viagra and cialas
viagra and depression
buy cheap free online viagra viagra
order viagra usa
cheapest viagra on line
buy female viagra
buy online online viagra viagra
discount viagra perscription drug
order viagra here
buy cheap deal pill viagra
buy taladafil viagra
discount viagra sales
buy cheap viagra online now
order viagra online
buy viagra online in uk
buy kamagra viagra
buy cialis online
order viagra onlines
cheapest line viagra
cheap kamagra viagra
order viagra cialis levitra pharmacy
buy viagra 100mg
buy viagra prescription
buy viagra online online pharmacy
buy viagra per pill
buy real viagra online pharmacy
buy viagra in bangkok
cheapest viagra in uk
viagra buying
cheap viagra uk
discount viagra pharmacy online
buy lipitor
buy real viagra
buy crestor
buy cheap viagra 32
discount viagra drug
buy cheap viagra online now uk
buy discount cialis
buy line viagra
buy viagra online 35008 buy
buy viagra at safeway
buy viagra without prescription online pharmacy
buy online purchase viagra
order viagra canada
buy cheap discount levitra
cheap deal pill pill viagra
Buy viagra Pittsburgh
viagra and hair loss
buy prescription vaniqa viagra
viagra buy do nu
discount viagra prescription drug
cheap man viagra
discount viagra online
cheap viagra online order viagra now
cheapest viagra anywhere
buy viagra online at cheap price
buy herbal viagra
buy viagra where
buy viagra softtabs
viagra buy viagra online
cheap generic viagra substitutes
order viagra prescription
buy viagra and cilas
buy in uk viagra
cheap pfizer viagra
buy in online usa viagra
viagra buy generic
buy evista
buy claritin
buy sildenafil viagra
buy buy online viagra viagra
buy citrate generic sildenafil viagra
buy cipro
buy cheap viagra viagra viagra
buy levitra online viagra
order viagra viagra
cheap online purchase viagra
cheap generic viagra online
buy gw porn viagra
buy real viagra pharmacy online
cheap herbal sale viagra viagra viagra
order viagra or levitra
discount viagra mastercard
buy discount viagra
buy viagra from an online pharmacy
cheap generic substitute viagra
buy viagra in new zealand
cheap canadian viagra
buy cheap sale viagra
buy viagra generic
buy viagra in london
viagra buy
cheap viagra cialis
cheap online sales viagra
buy viagra online no prescription
cialis 32
order site viagra
buy cheap online prescription viagra
Buy viagra Long Beach
order viagra visit your doctor online
cheapest generic viagra and canada
buy viagra and cilas usa
Buy viagra Nashville
cheap soft tab viagra
Buy viagra San Antonio
buy prescription viagra
buy viagra sale
viagra and hearing loss
buy cheap viagra prescription online
order levitra
cheapest viagra generic substitute
viagra by mail canada
cheapest prices on generic viagra
buy viagra in great britain
buy viagra search find free
buy viagra cheap india pharmacy
order viagra licensed pharmacies online
viagra buy ionline
Buy viagra New Orleans
order viagra online consumer rx
cheep viagra from india
buy cheap viagra
buy deal deal price viagra
buy viagra online in the uk
over the counter drug to viagra
buy viagra without prescription
check generic order pay viagra
buy celebrex
cheap deal discount viagra viagra
cheap molde ticket viagra
cheap viagra in the uk
viagra by mail
buy viagra bradenton
seroquel
buy viagra low cost
cheapest viagra in uk cheap
discount viagra viagra
buy internet viagra
buy viagra by pill
Buy viagra Washington
buy viagra with paypal
viagra buy uk
buy viagra uk
Buy viagra Phoenix
buy discount viagra online
cheapest place to buy viagra
order forms for buying viagra
buy online drug viagra pharmacy
cheapest viagra online pharmacy
buy generic viagra usa
purchase levitra
buy online uk viagra
cheap discount lexapro online
cheap meltabs viagra
cheapest prescription viagra
buy viagra online canada
buy viagra pills
cheap drug online prescription viagra
cheap sale viagra
buy locally viagra
buy viagra in uk
cheap levitra online
cheap deal discount price viagra
buy cheap viagra online
buy online sale viagra
viagra buy viagra
buy levitra viagra
buy diflucan
buy viagra online
buy viagra in reliable online drugstore
order mexican viagra
buy viagra from brazil
viagra and cialis side effects
buy viagra onlines
Buy viagra Tacoma
viagra buy now pay later
discount viagra generic
cheapest viagra price
buy viagra buy cheap viagra index
buy cheap viagra online uk
buy cheap viagra online u
cheapest viagra and regalis
cheap viagra online uk
buy carisoprodol no prescription
viagra and cialis
buy diovan
discount levitra
levitra online
buy free viagra on internet
viagra canada price
discount viagra pills
order viagra international ships
cheapest generic silagra viagra
buy now cialis
order viagra online no rx prescription
buy cost low viagra
buy cheap viagra on the net
discount viagra order viagra discount viagra
buy viagra online order
cheap herbal viagra viagra viagra
order viagra softtabs
buy 100 mg viagra
cheapest viagra online
buy online viagra securely buy phentermine
cheap online pill viagra
cheap viagra canada
cheap uk viagra
buy form generic viagra
cheap websites for viagra
cheap lexapro online
Buy viagra Riverside
buy p viagra
buy cialis canada
cheapest viagra online plus zenegra
cheap generic viagra uk
buy viagra online cheap
order cialis online
buy now online viagra
buy norvasc
discount viagra offers
cheap viagra generic
buy cheap viagra in uk
buy viagra on-line
buy cheap generic online viagra
order viagra air travel
cheap cheap herbal viagra viagra viagra
order discount viagra
cheapest viagra uk
buy viagra for cheap
cheapest viagra us licensed pharmacies
buy lexapro
discount viagra in the usa
buy generic viagra pharmacy online
buy viagra online and get prescription
cheapest viagra tablets
cheap cheap viagra viagra
cheap overnight viagra
buy viagra for women
order viagra on-line
cheap viagra no prescription
cheap viagra 25mg
Buy viagra Oxnard
cialis 50mg
buy viagra online 35008 buy viagra
buy viagra in amsterdam
cheap viagra from pfizer
viagra canada prescription
order 50mg viagra
buy viagra price drugs on
discount viagra canada
buy cheap generic viagra online
buy buy sale viagra viagra
buy viagra australian
cheap price viagra
buy viagra at the best price
viagra by money order
imitrex
buy free viagra viagra
buy viagra order viagra
buy levitra canada
order viagra buying viagr
buy online levitra cialis viagra
cheap prescription viagra without
buy discount viagra viagra viagra
cheapest viagra substitute sildenafil
discount viagra brand drug
cheap mexico viagra
cheap online price price viagra
cheap viagra buy pharmacy online now
viagra and cialis and
order cheap viagra fas
cheap cialis online
buy viagra cheap through online sales
buy site viagra
buy caverta
order prescription viagra without
buy online pharmacy viagra
buy online pill viagra
buy viagra online 3$ per pill
cheap deal pill viagra viagra
cheapest price for viagra and cialis
buy overseas viagra
buy cheapest online viagra
cheap viagra kamagra
order viagra now viagra money order
cheapest price on viagra
buy herbal pill viagra viagra
buy real viagra online
Buy viagra Mesa
buy discount levitra
cheap viagra without prescription
discount viagra or cialis
buy viagra 32
Buy viagra Kansas City
cheapest price for viagra
buy cheap viagra on
buy cheap discount lexapro
buy viagra 50mg
buy online viagra in the uk
viagra and diabetes
buy cheap uk viagra
cheap viagra st
buy viagra contact us page
buy isoptin
cheaper cialis levitra viagra
cheap pharmaceutical viagra
over the counter drugs like viagra
buy online price viagra
discount viagra sale online
cheapest viagra overnight
buy now levitra
buy herbal viagra longer erections
cheap discount viagra
buy viagra cheap fed ex
cialis 1
buy buy cheap viagra
cheap online generic viagra
cheap viagra online pharmacy online
Buy viagra Memphis
buy cozaar
cheap viagra index
buy viagra woman
buy viagra inte
cheap drug retin viagra wellbutrin
buy viagra australia
buy online online pill viagra viagra
buy imitrex
buy nolvadex
order telephone viagra overnight delivery
order viagra
buy online viagra viagra viagra
cheap viagra ambien generic cananda
discount cialis
buy cheap site viagra
buy depakote
order viagra uk
cheap viagra direct